If You're Stronghearted & Zoe Vs. The Devil
Review by Michael Oliver
In January, two one-act plays written and directed by Charlottetown Rural High School student Alix MacLean delighted audiences at Beaconsfield Carriage House .
If You're Stronghearted and Zoe Vs. The Devil both depict the world of adolescence with a sympathetic vision of its problems and a vivid understanding of its hopefulness. The bright young company assembled by MacLean performed both plays with humour, verve, and likable simplicity.
If You're Stronghearted is based on Milton Acorn's poem by that name. "I don't like poetry, but this is kinda cool," says the student Ilsa, played by Dawn Doiron, in the finest scene of this fine play. Doiron's intensity is matched by Wade Lynch's pomposity as the bitter teacher Mr. Matthews who keeps rambling on and on about the times he talked with Acorn-failing utterly to teach the poem.
Ilsa and her two friends Daphne and Fletcher, played by the author MacLean and Colin MacDonald, are left to find the meaning of the poem on their own. The meaning they discover is the play itself, a parable of friendship in diversity. These students-and the author-find the message they desire in the poem. Never mind the fact that their interpretation is far-fetched; the point is that they find it for themselves.
If You're Stronghearted is a better crafted play than Zoe Vs. The Devil, perhaps because MacLean is deeply fond of Acorn's poetry, and this was not the first production of the play. In fact, If You're Stronghearted was presented last year at the Eastern School District Drama Festival.
Zoe Vs. The Devil has too many characters and far too broad a theme-normality in adolescence is the working of the Devil-for a one-act play. And yet it has its bright spots. Best of all is making Satan and his human adversary out to be two teenage girls, played with stylish wit by Dawn Doiron and Diana Love. The author is not preaching feminism in these plays. It seems there is no need. The girls assume heroic functions without any fuss-suggesting that this is the proper scheme of things. This means, of course, the boys in these two plays are somewhat vague and wimpy. Fletcher, for example, in If You're Stronhearted, is intended to be funny, but perhaps his type is common nowadays, so it is easy for MacLean to upset gender roles.
In Zoe Vs. The Devil all the players were convincing, even in the least demanding parts. Ian Dunsford, Whitney Kelly, Alana Reddin, Jason Gus MacDonald, and Heather Stewart rounded out the story but had little opportunity to shine within the limitations of their roles.
Alix MacLean will no doubt keep on writing dramas. What is promising about her work is that it is not centred totally upon herself. If You're Stronghearted and Zoe Vs. The Devil both exhibit two strong roles for girls, not just one part to serve as mouthpiece for the author, as so often happens in the theatre. What MacLean should work on is the structure of her dramas. If You're Stronghearted and Zoe Vs. The Devil both build up suspense, but this is often broken awkwardly by scene shifts taking too much time. Especially in one-act plays there always must be something happening onstage to hold the built-up tension in the audience.
And yet, quite rightly so, the audience at Beaconsfield was mainly interested in appreciating all the fine young talent on display in these two entertaining plays.